The New Yahoo! Mail
Its a huge step forward but... let's be honest here... this is a face-lift on top of the same old mail engine. The back-end performing all the work hasn't changed in a long time. Still no support for IMAP. Still no support for the POP3 "LAST" command. And the SPAM filter on Yahoo seems to barely be working at all these days.
A question I've had on my mind for a long time is: why did it take so long for Yahoo to roll out what is basically nothing more than a reworked version of the Oddpost mail application that Yahoo bought in 2004? Don't companies buy other companies to get their products and bring the new product to market faster? It's faster to buy than to build? Microsoft lives by this practice.
I have to go with the service or product that gives me what I need and at the best cost (whether that be free or not). I really like the new Microsoft Live Mail UI, but even this product is nothing more than a face-lift... their back-end engine hasn't change either. And compared to Google an Yahoo, Microsoft is way behind the group with the features in their Live Mail offering. Right now Google Apps has what I'm looking for and its free. I'm happy to pay a low price for what I need, but free is always nice. Google lets me host my own domain on their mail servers, they have a decent UI and their SPAM filter is by far the best I've ever seen (its more than 99% accurate in my experience). Sure, Yahoo has Personal Address and the price is OK, but you only get 5 accounts and I have no idea whether they support aliases and whether the alias counts as one of the 5 accounts that you get. And on top of that, their SPAM filtering stinks (compared to Google).
Maybe some day I'll find the time to post a comparison chart of the features offered (and missing) in each of these products. I evaluate each of these products periodically in order to make sure I'm getting the best product, with the features I need, and at the best price. I recently switched from Yahoo to Google Apps and it looks like I'll be with Google for a while... unless Microsoft and Yahoo start moving a little faster with their feature offerings.
